Readers’ stories: T. Edmund Harvey – Liberal Quaker, Quaker Liberal

The sixth in our series of readers’ stories is by Mark Frankel, who’s two years into a PhD on T. Edmund Harvey at Birmingham University. Mark visits the Library regularly to read Harvey’s unpublished papers and his copious publications.

I’ve come to Quakerism late in life, having been a member of the Religious Society of Friends since 2009. I’m now 67, a retired civil servant, my last job having been in an agency of HM Treasury. A few years ago I did a Masters in Philosophy and it was the obvious philosophical training and intellectual rigour in Harvey’s passage 23.88 in Quaker Faith & Practice that first sparked my interest in him. I explain this further in a video I did for the Centre for Research into Quaker Studies (Why I am researching T. Edmund Harvey).

T. Edmund Harvey (1875-1955) was a prominent British Quaker of the first half of the twentieth century.  Born into a wealthy Quaker family in Leeds, he was educated at Oxford, Berlin and Paris.  He was warden of Toynbee Hall, the university settlement in the East End of London, from 1906 to 1911.  From 1904 to 1907 he was a member of the London County Council, and from 1909 to 1911 a Stepney borough councillor.  In 1910 he entered Parliament as the Liberal MP for West Leeds but stood down at the post-war election in 1918 because of criticism by his constituency party of his pacifist stance during the First World War.  He returned to Parliament briefly in 1923-1924, again as a Liberal, and for a longer stretch from 1937 as an Independent Progressive sitting for the now abolished constituency of the Combined English Universities.  He retired from Parliament aged 70 at the General Election in July 1945 and died in Leeds aged 80 in May 1955.

Harvey was a staunch Liberal.  He believed in ethical capitalism; in the British Empire as, on balance, a force for good; in duty to God and country; in gradual and orderly social reform; and in prudent public finance.  He could also be called an Establishment figure, as he moved smoothly in the corridors of power.  Yet he was a man of great integrity whose public life is marked by a well-worked-out commitment to the Quaker Testimonies.  It was his influence and eloquence that in 1916 brought about the statutory exemption from military conscription for conscientious objectors, and it was his dedication to the Peace Testimony allied with an equal dedication to public service which led to exempted conscientious objectors being placed in alternative civilian work through the agency of the Pelham Committee.  Harvey’s papers from the Pelham Committee (part of Library of the Society of Friends, Temp MSS 835) show how hard he worked on the practical aspects of the Peace Testimony.  The record is silent on how Harvey felt when the exemption hard won by his skill and dedication was spurned by the absolutists.

A former Librarian at Friends House, Ted Milligan, knew Harvey personally and has given me chapters from an unpublished biography.   The Library  has been important to my research for the papers of Pelham Committee, but also for reference material, particularly the unpublished Dictionary of Quaker Biography; for copies of Quaker periodicals from the era; for specialist secondary works on Quaker-related topics in the first half of the twentieth century; and for published works by Harvey himself and his contemporaries.  Harvey was the author of some fifty books and articles including The Rise of the Quakers (1905), A Wayfarer’s Faith (1913) The Long Pilgrimage, (the Swarthmore Lecture of 1921), St Aelred (1932) and Workaday Saints (1949),  all of which are held by the Library.

Harvey’s writings show his love not only of the Society of Friends, but also of neglected by-ways of the historic Christian Church with its lost sacraments and forgotten saints and sages.  There is also evidence of a teasing sense of humour.  Stolen Aureoles (1922) is a set of spoof hagiographies.  In it, Harvey mocks his own privileged background and reputation for equivocation with a bogus account of the trial of the early Christian saint, Eutychus:

When brought before the magistrate, Eutychus was at once surrounded by a cloud of false witnesses, one of whom accused him of having secreted vast wealth by his superstitious rites: to this the Saint simply replied that his treasure was in heaven.  Others swore that by the use of magic arts, he had frequently been known to face both ways at once, and that he had even made black appear white by uttering certain words which he was wont to use for such purposes.  At this the judge became filled with anger, and commanded the Saint to be thrown into a cauldron of seething hot water, which had been prepared hard by.  And lo! by a miracle marvellous to relate, as the water touched the Saint it became lukewarm, and the bubbling waves sank down, as though one had poured oil upon them.  (Stolen Aureoles p.19).

Posted in Readers' stories | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Some Library highlights of 2018

It’s time to take stock as the old year draws to a close. It’s been a full one. We said goodbye to old colleagues and welcomed new ones. Centenaries kept us busy. The reading room got a new look. Our online catalogue was unavailable for nearly a week because of a provider problem, but thanks to our membership of Copac we were able to provide alternative access. We supported the work of Friends House departments, and local Quakers. We welcomed readers and visiting groups, and we went out to visit Quaker meetings and other events to talk about the Library and its collections. New connections continued to be made through our Facebook page and Twitter account.

Reading room postersHere is a small selection of the highlights of 2018.

New manuscript accessions

Each year we receive new accessions into our collections as gifts from donors, including personal papers of Quaker individuals and families, archives of independent Quaker organisations, and also artworks and museum objects.

One of our favorite accessions this year was the Armfield family collection which has already featured on the blog. We were also presented with an original land deed for William Penn for land in Pennsylvania, showing there are still 17th century treasures held in private hands waiting to emerge. We received personal papers from some familiar names relating to Quaker witness in the 20th century: Bernard and Naomi Lawson, ‘Jack’ and Ruth Catchpool, and Alison Kelly. These personal papers always add an intimate insight into the lives and work of Quakers whose names appear frequently in the central Quaker archives either as committee members or workers. We can’t feature every gift we receive, but keep an eye out on the catalogue for new collections being added. We are grateful to donors who are willing to part with wonderful family collections to enrich the Library’s research collections.

New publications on Quakerism and Quaker history

2018 was a bumper year for new books and articles written by Library users. To highlight just a few – William Penn: a life, a long wished for new biography by Andrew Murphy; Rosemary Moore and Richard Allen’s The Quakers 1656-1723: the evolution of an alternative community; and New critical studies on early Quaker women 1650-1800, by Michele Tarter and Catie Gill. Thanks to these scholars and to the many others who have donated copies of their published research to the Library.    

Work with Friends

A large part of the Library’s work is not often featured on this blog – work to support Quakers around the country. Besides providing support to local Quaker meeting librarians, we also offer advice to meetings on how to manage their records, which eventually become archives. This encompasses published guidance and bespoke advice on cataloguing and depositing with local archives, but also issues like data protection and digital record-keeping – something that has kept us quite busy this year, with the introduction of GDPR. We ran a special interest session on data protection at Yearly Meeting in May, and later in the year visited one regional Quaker meeting to talk about digital challenges and opportunities, and explore ways local Quaker meetings can get their heritage online.

Library displays and loans for exhibition

Library users will be aware of the limitations of our modest reading room display cabinet. We do what we can: the final display of 2018 featured prison bars and even a World War II prisoner of war camp bedstead – in miniature! The reading room itself got a new look early in the year with some large scale facsimile posters of a variety of collection items. Table-top displays were prepared for visiting groups, including Friends from Cambridgeshire Area Meeting, a group of young Norwegian Quakers, and a party of sixth form religious education students from Hampshire. During Yearly Meeting we had two displays, one on the book of discipline and one on World War II relief work, both well received.

Items from display on World War II relief work at Yearly Meeting 2018

Items from display on World War II relief work at Yearly Meeting 2018

We’re also glad to be able to reach a wider audience by loaning items for display elsewhere in the country. You may have read about Chichester University’s Otter Gallery exhibition Conflicting Views: Pacifist Artists, which included 11 items on loan from our collections, including paintings, drawings, pamphlets and sculpture.

Collection care

Thanks to donors to our BeFriend A Book scheme, we continued work to preserve collections in the Library’s care. A further 18 “tract volumes” (composite volumes where several items are bound together), dating from the 17th to the early 19th century, received conservation treatment this year. You can read about some of that delicate work in an article posted in January.

Selection of tract volumes after conservation treatment

Selection of tract volumes after conservation treatment

Our much appreciated Arts Society conservation volunteers worked on steadfastly removing staples from 20th century pamphlets. This herculean task is expected to finish at the end of 2020, at which point we plan to move on to de-stapling newsletters and other periodical publications. Other volunteers help with a range of tasks, including checking accessions and carrying out small paper repairs. More difficult repairs have to be done professionally: as in previous years, we benefited from the work of a student conservator, who also wrote a blogpost on her work.

Happy new year!

To all our volunteers and BeFriend A Book donors, to our readers, friends/Friends and well-wishers, we say thank you, and good wishes for the new year ahead!


Posted in News | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Kristallnacht, Kindertransport, and help for refugees

10 year report cover_crop

Cover of report on ten years work by FCRA, 1943 (Library reference: 066.34 FCRA [1/32])

Last week saw the 80th anniversary of the November Pogrom in Germany and Austria, now known as Kristallnacht. This outburst of anti-Semitic violence happened over the night of the 9th/10th of November and was a clear indication of the direction Nazi racial policy was taking. Across Germany and Austria Jews were beaten  and burnt out of their homes, synagogues and Jewish businesses were destroyed, many Jews were killed and thousands more were arrested and sent to concentration camps.

British Jews, terrified to enter Germany under these conditions, asked Quakers to send a group of investigators to find out what was happening. Quakers and Jews had been working closely together to help refugees from Nazi persecution escape Germany since 1933.

A group went from Britain, and a concerned group of Quakers also came over from America. There was talk of an offer of relief for Jews on the ground, but it quickly became clear that relief was not what was needed, but evacuation.

Ben Greene, one of the British group, reported:

“The Jews are therefore dominated by the one thought of getting out of Germany. Again and again they emphasize that they asked for nothing more than a camp and a crust of bread – only to get out of Germany at any price. They see only the possible effects of the present conditions (a) death in a few months or (b) the establishment of Jewish Labour camps by the authorities. Most of the Jews preferred the former to prospect of a so-called Labour Camp.” (Library reference: FCRA/17/6)

The reports gathered from the Jewish community in Germany by Quakers were of influence when Quakers accompanied the Jewish delegation who went to see Home Secretary Sir Samuel Hoare to plead the case for allowing immigration of children into Britain without the usual visa restrictions. They swayed the government and this planned immigration of German and Austrian Jewish children became known as the Kindertransport. Around 10,000 children were evacuated from Germany and Austria to Britain between 1938 and 1939.

Although Quakers were involved in helping Jewish lobbyists pressure the government, making arrangements for children on the ground in Germany and Austria, and also when they came to Britain, we do not hold a large amount of archive records relating to the Kindertransport in the Library. Minutes refer briefly to the undertaking but there are no detailed records. Although an important event in the history of the Holocaust, and an event Quakers are proud to have played some part in, for Quakers at the time, it was a small part of the overall work they had been doing to assist refugees since 1933, and which would continue into the 1950s.

The records of Friends Service Council, Germany and Austria sections, include a lot of correspondence about the situation in these countries at that time, including some of the reports after Kristallnacht. Read with hindsight they make even more chilling accounts than they must have done at the time.

When two of the American delegation met with an official they referred to as Counsellor Hendrichs (referred to later as Counsellor Henrichs) at the Foreign Office in Berlin, they told him they had decided relief work on the ground did not look necessary (rather that evacuation of Jews was needed), and Henrichs remarked:

“No and there will not be such need [for relief], as we – the Germans – will not let Jews starve.” (Library reference: FSC/GE/5/6)

The records of the Friends Committee for Refugees and Aliens (FCRA), formerly the Germany Emergency Committee (GEC), record how they helped refugees, predominantly “non-Aryan Christians” (Christians who had Jewish parents or ancestry) escape from Nazi controlled Europe 1933-1950. These records include minutes covering policy and organisation, correspondence with other agencies involved in refugee work, and a very small number of case files. Unfortunately the majority of case files for refugees were destroyed after the war. There is a name index which lists approximately 8000 adults helped to escape by the Quakers over this period. It generally does not include the names of children, including those on the Kindertransport. The index is not open for general research but applications can be made to access the information via the library enquiries email:

We have developed a new subject guide to help anyone who wants to undertake research into World War Two era refugees (c.1933-1950s) in our collections; it can be found as the featured resource alongside our other subject guides on this page:

Please read the guide and get in touch should you wish further information or to arrange a visit.


FCRA pamphlet to raise funds for refugees from Nazi Germany and Austria, c.1938 (Library reference: 066.34 [FCRA 3/6])

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Friends at the end of World War I: seeking international peace

At various points during the last four years we have marked the centenary of World War I on this blog by highlighting our collections relating to aspects of Quaker work at that time, including the relief work of the Friends War Victims Relief Committee and support for conscientious objectors. As the centenary draws to a close this November, it seems appropriate to look at what our collections tell us about how Quakers in 1918 felt peace could be achieved after the war.

Amongst our archives from the time are the records of the Friends League of Nations Committee, later the Friends League of Nations Association, which began with a preliminary meeting held in London on 24 July 1918.

In January that year, the US president, Woodrow Wilson, had spoken about his proposed Fourteen Points for peace, which included a proposal for a League of Nations. When Yearly Meeting considered the report of the Peace Committee in May, it was reported in The Friend that Joseph B. Braithwaite urged support for the idea, as the only practical proposal for peace that had been put forward, referring to William Penn in arguing that peace had to be backed up by force if needed. Other Friends present differed, unable to support a League which rested on the threat of force.

Joseph B. Braithwaite was one of those who gathered on 24 July to consider the matter, with the minutes of the meeting recording that:

“The Friends present were unanimously of opinion that although the late Yearly Meeting of the Society declined to take any action endorsing the proposal for a League of Nations, there were a very large number of Friends, who were anxious to participate in this piece of constructive work for Peace, and that steps should be taken to ascertain if this is so.”

Letter inviting support for President Wilson's proposals

Letter inviting support for President Wilson’s proposal for a league of nations, signed by J B Braithwaite, Robert Marsh and Harry Gilpin (1918) (Library ref: Box 232/7)

An appeal was drafted to be printed and circulated , asking for people to respond with their views. The letter referred again to William Penn, drawing parallels between his 1693 Essay towards the present and future peace of Europe  and recent statements in favour of the League of Nations by Viscount Grey, the former Foreign Secretary.

By the time the new Friends League of Nations Committee met again on 4 September 1918, they reported that they had so far received 2092 assents and 112 dissents to their letter.

The Committee’s activities increased. They held a meeting of supporters at Devonshire House on 1 November 1918, and sent a minute to Meeting for Sufferings, recommending “drastic control” of the production of armaments, and “a solemn international compact to employ such material solely under the sanction of the League of Nations for the maintenance of international peace based upon Right, Justice and Liberty, and for the protection of peoples threatened with injustice and oppression…”.

The Friend reported on a further conference at Devonshire House on 21 November, called by the Peace Committee of Meeting for Sufferings. At the conference the discussions continued, with speakers like Carl Heath again questioning whether Quakers should actively support a League of Nations if the purpose was not disarmament, while J. Bevan Braithwaite continued to argue that, “As long as evil was in the world, force must be employed to repress it, if necessary, otherwise anarchy would prevail.”

Report of the 21 November conference at Devonshire House, The Friend (29 Nov 1918)

Report of the 21 November conference at Devonshire House, The Friend (29 Nov 1918)

The Friends League of Nations Committee became the Friends League of Nations Association in 1919 and continued to operate until 1921, when it was decided that it was no longer needed as a separate body, following the decision of Meeting for Sufferings in February that year to establish a League of Nations Watching Committee.

The Library holds the minutes of the Friends League of Nations Association and the Propaganda Committee, and of the League of Nations Watching Committee (1921-1925).

Friends League of Nations Committee first minute book

Friends League of Nations Committee first minute book

Posted in Highlights | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Caring for the past: conserving the Library’s collection of pamphlets and booklets

Lizzie Fuller, trainee conservator, writes about her work with some of our 19th and 20th century pamphlets.

As a trainee Paper Conservator, I am fortunate to have opportunities to work on fascinating objects and this summer was no exception when I was given the chance to carry out conservation treatment on the Library of the Society of Friends’ collection of booklets and pamphlets as part of my student placement at Sussex Conservation Consortium. As I worked through the booklets it was interesting to uncover the breadth of areas that the Quakers have been involved with, as well as the diverse variety of pamphlet styles.

Reducing a heavy layer of animal glue on one booklet

Reducing a heavy layer of animal glue on one booklet

Paper conservation involves the stabilisation of paper-based objects in order to improve long-term preservation. For the pamphlet and booklet project, my treatment involved removing deteriorated elements such as rusting staples and degraded pressure-sensitive tape, which were causing damage to the paper as well as staining and would result in more damage in the future. I also reduced thick areas of animal glue that were restricting the opening of covers and re-adhered the lifted spine materials using wheatstarch paste and Japanese repair papers. Following the removal of staples, I re-sewed the bindings and tipped in any loose inserts with a Japanese paper hinge to prevent them from getting lost. As an organic material, paper naturally degrades and conservation plays an essential role in mitigating against this so that objects are protected and preserved for years to come.

Lifting degraded adhesive tape

Lifting degraded adhesive tape

I am currently in my second year of study at Camberwell College of Arts, University of the Arts, London, and this student placement has contributed to the development of my practical skills, as well as providing valuable experience of a professional environment. Sussex Conservation Consortium is a small private studio owned jointly by Ian Watson and Ruth Stevens, both accredited Book and Library Materials Conservators. I particularly benefited from working under the supervision of two experienced conservators and applying some of their wealth of knowledge to my work. My placement was a really enjoyable and useful experience and I am very grateful for the Library’s agreement to me working on these valued and important objects.

A booklet sewn together after removing staples

A booklet sewn together after removing staples

You can support work to conserve the Library’s collections by donating to our BeFriend a Book appeal. Please email or write to us for more information about the appeal.





Posted in Collection care | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Open, healthy, scrupulously clean, with a liberal table: the Armfields and their temperance hotel

This year the Library was given a collection relating to the Armfield family who ran Armfield’s South Place Temperance Hotel near Finsbury Circus, London, during the second half of the 19th century.

The collection includes a visitors’ book chronicling guests from 1857 to 1869, a copy of Joseph John Armfield’s memoir, and personal family papers, as well as photographs and publicity material relating to the hotel.

Joseph John Armfield's Journal cover

Joseph John Armfield, Journal (Library reference MSS 1035/1)

Joseph Armfield (1821-1894), the head of this branch of the family, was a conservative Quaker who held to the principles of plain dress and plain speech. His religious views were described by his son Joseph John as “extreme”, “strict”, and “orthodox”. He was an active member of the Society of Friends, publishing two tracts and serving on numerous committees. He had taken the temperance pledge in 1839, at the age of 18, and his brother was an ardent temperance campaigner, so it is unsurprising that he chose to run a temperance hotel.

Temperance hotels, like coffee taverns and temperance clubs, were one of a range of institutions set up by temperance campaigners to provide access to social and entertainment amenities without the temptation of alcohol being present.

Advertisement for temperance drinks in The Friend

Advertisement for temperance drinks in The Friend

The ideal temperance hotel should offer respectable food and lodging, a place for people to socialise and conduct business and, of course, a variety of non-alcoholic beverages. Unfortunately, temperance hotels generally had rather a poor reputation – they were often conversions of existing buildings run by those with little or no prior experience in the trade and, deprived of the profits that could be made from the sale of alcohol, were unable to offer luxuries. Even temperance campaigners were forced to admit that they were generally “not attractive”.

Joseph had worked as a clerk for various family owned businesses before opening the hotel with his wife Julia (née Ashby, 1813-1889) in 1857. They converted the house of a wealthy Jewish silk merchant and moved in with their three surviving children: Julia Anne (1850-1902), later author of Quaker tracts and member of Fritchley General Meeting, Joseph John (1852-1935), engineer, and Aaron Ashby (1854-1944)at who was eventually to take over from his father.

Despite the inexperience of the Armfields, and the building’s origins as a domestic dwelling, Armfield’s South Place Hotel proved very successful. It was situated at the corner of South Place and South Street, just north of Finsbury Circus. As we can see from this flyer, it was initially a single five-storey house with basement. Joseph John describes high-ceilinged rooms, mahogany-framed sash windows, and thick mahogany doors with ivory-inlaid door furniture, and recalls sitting on the balconies outside the first floor windows.

The hotel was advertised in both The Friend and the British Friend.

Advertisement for Armfields Hotel in The Friend (1857)

Advertisement in The Friend (1857)

No doubt bolstered by its location less than a mile from Devonshire House, where Yearly Meeting was held, Armfield’s had many Quaker guests. Representatives from all the well-known British Quaker families can be seen in pages of the visitors’ book – Sturges, Clarks, Pumphrys, Peases, Corders, Foxes, Bevans, Cadburys, Lloyds and Rowntrees, among others. There were also numerous American Quaker visitors, including members of the Bettle and Turnbull families and James E. Rhoads – president of Bryn Mawr College.

A page from Armfield's Hotel visitors' book

A page from Armfield’s Hotel visitors’ book (Library reference MSS 1035/2/2)

Joseph John recalls in his memoir that he and his siblings were sent away during Yearly Meeting each year. “Our hotel was conveniently near [Devonshire House] & Friends to the full capacity of its accommodation stayed there during that time; & it was a relief no doubt to our parents to get us young children out of the way during that period… I expect our room in London was more acceptable than our company”.

It was not only Quakers who stayed at Armfield’s. Other figures engaged in social and public work chose the hotel, including abolitionist Harriet Beecher Stowe, temperance campaigner Asbjorn Kloster and missionary Elias Schrenk. Ten men from temperance-led life insurance company Sceptre Life Association are noted in the guest book as expressing “their entire satisfaction with the attention received and the accommodation afforded”. As a budding engineer, Joseph John enthusiastically recalls dining with sea captains and the inventor of the screw propeller.

In the early 1870s it was decided that Aaron Ashby (Ashby to his family) would become his father’s apprentice, partner, and then successor at the hotel. In 1873 Julia Armfield was in ill health, so she and Joseph moved out of the hotel to Croydon, leaving Ashby living in the hotel. Ashby held less strict religious views than his father, and over the next 30 years the hotel’s character gradually changed.

Armfields group photograph, with Ashby and Helen Armfield centre

Armfields group photograph, with Ashby and Helen in the centre

The hotel was advertised in the British Friend as having been enlarged and redecorated. Joseph John mentions that the hotel eventually grew to encompass five houses going down South Street and an additional building on South Place. At this point it had 70 bedrooms, coffee, commercial and private sitting rooms, a ladies drawing room and smoking and billiard rooms furnished by well-known billiard table manufacturers Burroughs and Watts.

Advertisement for Armfield's South Place Hotel in the British Friend (1 May 1886)

Advertisement in the British Friend (1886)

In 1891, the hotel was completely rebuilt and accommodation doubled. Publicity photographs and a brochure in our archive give a good idea of what the rebuilt hotel would have been like.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The exterior is markedly different from the converted house and the rooms are comfortably decorated with art and fine furniture. The hotel boasts modern facilities – the telephone room (visible in the back of the entrance hall), a lift, electric lights, modern sanitary arrangements and hot and cold water on all floors. The hotel also now includes a separate restaurant available to rent for parties. Whereas the advertisements of earlier decades emphasised cleanliness and health, those of the 1880s and 1890s stress comfort and modernity.

Advertisement in the British Friend (1894)

Advertisement in the British Friend (1894)

More radically, the establishment ceased to be a temperance hotel. Temperance is not mentioned in the pamphlet or advertisement in The British Friend, and in 1897 an advertisement in The Freemason specifically states that it was now fully licensed.

There is no guestbook for this period, but we were able to find out a few of the hotel patrons from other sources. In 1895 King Khama of the Bamangwato people of Bechuanaland (now Botswana) stayed at the hotel whilst in London. Opposite Armfield’s was the South Place Chapel, home of the South Place Ethical Society (now called Conway Hall Ethical Society). Its periodical, The Ethical Record advertised a Sunday school and dances held in Armfield’s (thanks to staff at Conway Hall library for finding further links between the Ethical Society and the Armfields out at Croydon).

The Armfield family stopped being associated with the hotel at some point in the 1910s. It is thought by the family that the building was requisitioned by the government during World War One. We can see from this postcard that it was still operating in 1916.

Armfield's Hotel postcard written in 1916

Armfield’s Hotel postcard, 1916 (private collection)

An auction of the hotel’s contents was advertised in the Pall Mall Gazette (12 January 1918), marking the end of the story of Armfield’s South Place Hotel. The building itself was destroyed during the blitz, so although there is still a South Place Hotel on the site today, it bears no relation to the original Armfield’s.

The newly catalogued Armfield Papers provide a fascinating record of one Quaker family and their flourishing temperance enterprise in the latter part of 19th century.

Posted in New accessions | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Conflicting Views: Pacifist Artists – the Otter Gallery loan

Loaning material to other institutions provides an exciting opportunity to bring our collections to new audiences around the country. Special collections curator Melissa Atkinson writes about a current loan, and describes some of the objects on view.

I was approached by Gill Clarke, Visiting Professor at the Otter Gallery, University of Chichester, with an exciting exhibition proposal about pacifist war artists. Our collections hold a wealth of material about pacifism, conflict and the Friends Ambulance Unit archive from the First and Second World Wars.

The exhibition, Conflicting Views: Pacifist Artists, aimed to explore the ways artists who were conscientious objectors and pacifists responded to conflicts through their art. It would mark the centenary of the ending of the First World War but expand beyond the early 20th century.

After many visits and discussions, I showed Gill a selection of material from which she chose specific artwork. A loan application was made 6 months in advance of the exhibition, requesting to borrow 11 items from our collections. We scrutinised the application, looking at security and environmental gallery conditions as well as examining the artworks for suitability. The artworks selected were in a diverse collection of formats, from a sculpture and large watercolour panel to small prints and a hardback book.

Gill went away to write the exhibitions catalogue and I started to focus on conditions reports for each item, examining any faults and potential issues for long-term display plus art valuations for insurance purposes.

Fine art movers Cadogan Tate came on the scheduled day in early June and expertly packed the art. The next time I saw our artwork was at the opening of the exhibition of Conflicting Views: Pacifist Artists. What a joy to see parts of our collection out of the Library and hanging in a gallery to be discovered by a new audience.

Loan artworks

Four items were borrowed from the Ernest Procter Collection including two works by him – Untitled (SSA at HQ Loading Up) February 6, 1917 (EPC_03) and SSA 14 at Somme Suippe (EPC_04);  a pencil drawing by Allen Chandler (1887-1969) entitled Whit Monday, 1915, The Dressing Station, Augustine Straat, Ypres (EPC_01) and a pencil sketch Aide Poste Cellar, SSA 19, at Nieuport Bains by Arthur Cotterell (1885-1961) (EPC_02).

Ernest Procter (1886-1935) was one of many artists who volunteered with the FAU. He trained as an orderly but worked as an artist. He visited different SSA units in France and Belgium making sketches and drawings of his experiences. Section Sanitaire Anglaise was the name given to Red Cross, FAU & Order of St John ambulance units. We hold 80 artworks from this Quaker artist, consisting of drawings, sketches and watercolours, all from his time with the FAU from 1916 to 1919.

Ernest Procter. SSA at HQ loading up (1917)

Ernest Procter. Untitled (SSA at HQ Loading Up) February 6, 1917 (Library reference EPC_03)

Ernest Procter. SSA 14 at Somme Suippe

Ernest Procter. SSA 14 at Somme Suippe. Pencil and charcoal sketch (Library reference EPC_04)

Allen Chandler. Whit Monday, 1915, The Dressing Station, Augustine Straat, Ypres

Allen Chandler. Whit Monday, 1915, The Dressing Station, Augustine Straat, Ypres (Library reference: EPC_01)

The Passers-by on a road near La Panne, Belgium, 1916 by Donald Wood (1889-1953) is a framed watercolour panel. Donald Wood was an artist from Leeds whose parents were Quakers. He was in the FAU from 1915 to 1919, working as an orderly and a driver in the SSA 14 unit.

Donald Wood. Passersby on a road near La Panne. Detail

Detail of Passersby on a road near La Panne by Donald Wood (1916)(Library reference F002)

Four prints by George P. Micklewright (1893-1951) who drew satirical cartoons of being a conscientious objector in prison during WWI. Micklewright was an absolutist who refused to be involved in any aspect of the war. He was arrested, fined and imprisoned at Lichfield, then moved to Warwick, Wormwood Scrubs and Dartmoor prisons. Micklewright went on to be a successful book jacket illustrator for crime and science fiction books.

George P Micklewright. C.O.s at Dartmoor

George P Micklewright. C.O.s at Dartmoor (Library reference 86_A81)


Hugo Powell. The Sentinel. Wooden sculpture

Hugo Powell. The Sentinel. Wooden sculpture

Sculpture entitled The Sentinel by Hugo Powell (1919-2014). Powell studied at Leighton Park, a Quaker school, and was a conscientious objector who volunteered with the FAU, travelling with the Hadfield Spears Field Hospital in North Africa and Europe in World War II. He was not a Quaker but was sympathetic to Quakerism. The sculpture was made in 1986 and is described as a wooden assemblage made from off-cuts from a boatyard and found objects in Powell’s studio that have been dowelled together.

‘Let others celebrate the solemnities of official memorials. Here is a private and affectionate remembrancer of the men of the First Free French Division and my years with them.’ Hugo Powell.

The Ghosts of the Slain by R. L. Outhwaite (1915), illustrated by Joseph Southall (1861-1944). Southall was a Quaker from Warwickshire Monthly Meeting and had a successful career as an artist and illustrator. As a socialist and pacifist, he also wrote about these topics.

Title page by Joseph E Southall for Ghosts of the Slain, by R L Outhwaite (1915)

Title page by Joseph E Southall for Ghosts of the Slain, by R L Outhwaite (1915)


Conflicting Views: Pacifist Artists will be on until 7 October 2018 at the Otter Gallery, University of Chichester.



In response to your comments, here are the other items loaned to the Otter Gallery for the Conflicting Views exhibition this summer.

Drawings by G P Micklewright and Arthur Cotterell


Posted in Exhibitions | Tagged , , , , , , , | 8 Comments